Case Study

A Historic Workers’ Compensation Result in California

Workers’ Compensation

Rafael Pineda’s case was turned down by five law firms. He was told there was no case because his injury happened while commuting.

Mr. Pineda, an iron worker, was riding a motorcycle on his way to work when he was struck by a car. He sustained a severe head trauma and spinal cord injuries. His claim was initially denied under the “Going and Coming Rule,” which is generally a complete bar to workers’ compensation benefits.

We found the exception. We proved the injury qualified as a work-related accident and that responsibility applied. The insurance company’s first offer was $10,000.

Exhaustive research on exceptions to the rule led to a victory at trial and, later, to a post-trial appeal victory. After depositions, trial, and an appeal, the case was resolved for $13.2 million, a historic workers’ compensation settlement in California negotiated by Michael Rott, Esq.

Results depend on the facts of each case. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Result

$13.2 million

A historic workers’ compensation settlement in California, negotiated by Michael Rott, Esq.

Attorney Michael Ian Rott with workers' compensation client Rafael Pineda at his home

Attorney Michael Rott with client Rafael Pineda.

Credentials

Professional Recognition You Can Trust.

Professional Recognition You Can Trust.

Verified recognition — click to view official listings.

Verified recognition.
Click to view official listings.

San Diego County Bar Association logo
Expert Network Distinguished Lawyer badge awarded to attorney Michael Rott
Avvo Clients' Choice Award badge for attorney David V. Hiden
Avvo Clients' Choice Award badge for attorney Michael Ian Rott
Hiden, Rott & Oertle BBB Accredited Business with an A+ rating since 2018
Super Lawyers rating badge for attorney Michael Rott

Get Started

Speak With an Experienced Workers’ Compensation Lawyer.

If you’ve been injured at work and need clear answers about your rights, benefits, or medical care, we’re here to help.

You may also contact us directly at 619-369-3323.

Start With a Free Consultation.

Disclaimer:

The use of the internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

No upfront costs. No obligation. Just clear guidance.